Five years after Congress created the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, a strange thing has happened: the problem it was built to solve kept getting smaller while the bureaucracy built to solve it kept getting bigger. 

That’s the real headline buried in a new analysis from the Advanced Communications Law and Policy Institute (ACLP) at New York Law School, “Sizing Up Another BEAD Round.” Since December 2022, 79% of the locations originally identified as eligible for BEAD funding have already been resolved, that is, served, no longer serviceable, or picked up by a different federal program. That’s up sharply from the 65% figure ACLP reported just last year. Nearly two-thirds carry no federal subsidy commitment at all. Private capital simply got there first. 

This should be celebrated as a success story. Instead, it has become a statutory headache, and a useful lesson in what happens when government moves at government speed while markets move at market speed. 

BEAD’s authorizing statute requires that at least 80% of a project’s funded locations be unserved. That threshold made sense when the map was drawn. It makes a lot less sense now that ACLP finds 69% of Round One projects no longer meet it, rising to 89% under the stricter “unserved” standard. Thirty-eight percent of originally awarded locations are simply gone from the table, already connected by someone else.  

The locations that remain are the hardest and most expensive ones left: the national average cost per remaining location has climbed from roughly $4,855 to $7,900 as the cheap, dense, profitable territory got built out from under the program. 

Some of that is a genuine success for competition and private investment. Some of it is a direct consequence of a program that was slow to get moving and slower still to look up and notice the ground had shifted. The Biden-era NTIA built a model, locked in a map, and largely stuck with it even as fiber and fixed wireless crews kept working the same territory in real time. The result, predictably, is that some awardees are now looking at their award areas and declining to move forward, not because they lack the will to build, but because the best, most financially workable locations inside their footprint have already been claimed by buildout that happened while NTIA’s clock was still ticking. 

That is not a scandal. It’s arithmetic. And it points to the fix: rebidding and rescoping, done deliberately rather than as an afterthought.  

A fresh round, sized to what ACLP estimates is roughly 1 million genuinely remaining eligible locations and roughly $5.3 billion in new funding, lets industry tell NTIA what it actually needs to make those harder, lower-density areas pencil out, rather than forcing providers to build to a scope drawn on data that was already stale when BEAD’s checks started clearing.  

NTIA Administrator Arielle Roth has signaled a willingness to let some of the program’s roughly $21 billion in unspent, “non-deployment” funds go toward improving the program itself rather than simply sitting idle. That’s the right instinct. ACLP’s recommendation that a meaningful reserve — on the order of $15 billion — be set aside for defaults, rising material and labor costs, and adoption barriers deserves serious attention as NTIA finalizes that guidance. 

None of this is an argument for shrinking BEAD’s ambition. The statute still requires the money to be spent, and spent on connecting Americans who genuinely lack service. The argument is for spending it well: on the roughly one million locations that are actually left, under cost assumptions that reflect 2026 realities rather than a 2022 snapshot. No more pretending the permitting gauntlet — a median of eight to eleven separate permitting triggers per project-county, spanning 2,449 counties and 12,146 municipalities — is someone else’s problem to solve later. 

Refocusing BEAD projects to match the statute isn’t red tape; it’s the opposite. It’s NTIA doing exactly what every taxpayer should want from an agency entrusted with $42 billion: watching the facts change, and changing course with them.  

The market closed most of the digital divide before the government finished drawing its map. The least Washington can do now is stop building to the old one. 

Innovation Economy Alliance